Trafigura's marine fuel division, TFG Marine, is taking a cautious approach to investing in alternative marine fuels despite the growing number of dual-fuel vessels. Kenneth Dam, executive director of TFG Marine, stated at a conference in Geneva that the company will not make major investments in alternative fuels until demand increases significantly. This stance comes as shipowners continue to order vessels capable of burning both conventional and alternative fuels like LNG.
The flexibility of dual-fuel vessels allows owners to delay switching to alternatives until the economics become more favorable. However, alternative fuels remain expensive. Since March, Singapore's very-low-sulfur fuel oil has averaged $822 per metric ton, a 66% increase from a year earlier, while biodiesel averaged $997 per ton and LNG averaged $1,325 per ton.
Conventional fuel oil has seen sustained demand due to the expanding shadow fleet transporting Russian and other sanctioned crude, as well as longer shipping routes. The Iran war has also disrupted supply, with October flows through Hormuz estimated to be at least 800,000 tons per month below February levels. Some analysts argue that these supply disruptions could encourage investment in alternative marine fuels for energy security reasons.
The regulatory landscape remains uncertain. The International Maritime Organization postponed its net-zero framework decision last year, with discussions set to resume in December. Europe has proposed subsidies to cover part of the price difference between conventional and alternative fuels, although the proposal still needs approval. Notably, biodiesel made from used cooking oil and animal fats would not qualify for these subsidies despite already being used by the shipping industry.