Skip to content
Back to the Guavy Wire
Crypto

Judge Dismisses $25M Ethereum Exploit Case Against MIT Brothers

Instruments
ETH
Share

A Manhattan federal judge has cleared Anton and James Peraire-Bueno of all charges related to a 2023 exploit that siphoned $25 million from Ethereum trading bots. Judge Jessica Clarke ruled that prosecutors failed to prove the brothers made a material misrepresentation, a key requirement for wire fraud. The decision ends the case without a retrial, following a mistrial last year when the jury deadlocked.

The case centered on an April 2023 scheme where the brothers allegedly exploited Ethereum's transaction ordering system. They placed bait transactions to lure specific bots, then used a relay bug to see the bots' trades before finalizing a block. In roughly 12 seconds, they swapped the bait transactions for profitable trades, leaving the bots with $25 million in losses. Authorities arrested the pair in May 2024, accusing them of planning the attack and laundering the proceeds.

Clarke noted that Ethereum is a 'trustless, highly adversarial environment with no terms of use,' arguing that the brothers' actions, while potentially immoral, did not constitute fraud. She also raised due process concerns about the prosecution but declined to rule on them. The money laundering charge was dismissed since it relied on the fraud counts.

The ruling is significant for the crypto industry, as it marks the first prosecution of its kind. Clarke described the case as a 'first of its kind' in her decision, a label the government itself had used in its indictment.

More on Crypto