Skip to content
Back to the Guavy Wire
Forex

High GIC Rates in Canada but Taxes and Inflation Cut Returns

Instruments
CAD
Share

Canadian savers are currently enjoying some of the highest guaranteed investment certificate (GIC) rates in years, with a five-year GIC offering a 4.55% return. Shorter-term options include 4.40% for three years and 4.30% for two years. Even savings accounts are paying more, with WealthONE now offering 3.25%. However, these rates may not be as attractive as they seem once taxes and inflation are factored in.

The latest inflation reading stands at 3.1%, leaving just a 1.45 percentage point gap before taxes between inflation and the best five-year GIC rate. The Bank of Canada predicts inflation will drop to around 2% by mid-2028, which could widen this gap. For someone in a 40% marginal tax bracket, the after-tax return on a five-year GIC falls to 2.73%, still above the Bank of Canada’s 2% target but below today’s inflation rate.

Where you hold your savings can significantly impact your returns. In a non-registered account, someone in the 40% tax bracket would keep just 2.73% of the 4.55% GIC rate after taxes. Holding the GIC in a tax-free savings account (TFSA) or a registered retirement savings plan (RRSP) can make a big difference, allowing you to earn the full 4.55% tax-free or defer taxes until withdrawal, respectively.

Locking in for five years may not be worth the extra interest. The best two-year GIC pays 4.30%, compared to 4.55% for five years, offering just $25 more annually over the first two years for a $10,000 investment. While locking in a higher rate can protect against future rate drops, it also means tying up your money for a longer period. Savings accounts, such as WealthONE’s 3.25% rate or EQ Bank’s 3.00% rate, offer flexibility for shorter-term needs, though their rates can change.

More on Forex