Canadian savers are currently enjoying some of the highest guaranteed investment certificate (GIC) rates in years, with a five-year GIC offering a 4.55% return. Shorter-term options include 4.40% for three years and 4.30% for two years. Even savings accounts are paying more, with WealthONE now offering 3.25%. However, these rates may not be as attractive as they seem once taxes and inflation are factored in.
The latest inflation reading stands at 3.1%, leaving just a 1.45 percentage point gap before taxes between inflation and the best five-year GIC rate. The Bank of Canada predicts inflation will drop to around 2% by mid-2028, which could widen this gap. For someone in a 40% marginal tax bracket, the after-tax return on a five-year GIC falls to 2.73%, still above the Bank of Canada’s 2% target but below today’s inflation rate.
Where you hold your savings can significantly impact your returns. In a non-registered account, someone in the 40% tax bracket would keep just 2.73% of the 4.55% GIC rate after taxes. Holding the GIC in a tax-free savings account (TFSA) or a registered retirement savings plan (RRSP) can make a big difference, allowing you to earn the full 4.55% tax-free or defer taxes until withdrawal, respectively.
Locking in for five years may not be worth the extra interest. The best two-year GIC pays 4.30%, compared to 4.55% for five years, offering just $25 more annually over the first two years for a $10,000 investment. While locking in a higher rate can protect against future rate drops, it also means tying up your money for a longer period. Savings accounts, such as WealthONE’s 3.25% rate or EQ Bank’s 3.00% rate, offer flexibility for shorter-term needs, though their rates can change.