Skip to content
Back to the Guavy Wire
Forex

New Zealand's Depositor Scheme Fuels Finance Company Boom and Risk Concerns

Instruments
NZD
Share

The Reserve Bank of New Zealand's latest Financial Stability Report reveals a significant surge in finance company deposits, which grew by 28% in the year to June. This rapid expansion is largely attributed to the introduction of the Depositor Compensation Scheme (DCS), which guarantees depositors up to $100,000 if a licensed deposit taker fails. The scheme's funding, however, relies on a levy-funded reserve that will take about 20 years to reach its target, with taxpayer dollars serving as the backup in the meantime.

The DCS is designed to protect everyday savers, but it may also be inadvertently subsidizing higher-risk finance companies. These institutions, which often engage in riskier lending practices such as property development and bridging finance, are now enjoying cheaper and more abundant funding due to the public guarantee. While finance companies play a crucial role in funding non-traditional borrowers, their higher net interest margins (above 3%) compared to banks (low-to-mid 2s) highlight the need for appropriate risk pricing.

The current levy structure charges finance companies in the highest-risk category about 70% more than major banks, but this may not adequately reflect the true credit risk. Comparisons with wholesale bond markets suggest that the spread demanded for lower-rated financial institutions can be up to fourteen times that of an AA-rated bank. This raises questions about whether the DCS levies are sufficiently pricing the risks they insure.

The scheme also introduces a moral hazard, as the influx of deposits could pressure finance companies to expand into riskier markets or loosen lending standards. The Reserve Bank has acknowledged this risk, noting that rapid balance-sheet growth and declining capital buffers could lead to increased risk-taking. To mitigate these issues, the author suggests pricing levies more accurately based on credit ratings, implementing growth limits, and increasing transparency about the risks taxpayers are underwriting.

More on Forex