John Singer Sargent’s 1909 charcoal portrait of Walter Murray Guthrie (1869-1911) stands out as one of his most striking male portraits. The drawing captures Guthrie in profile, a rare choice for Sargent that accentuates the sitter’s refined features. Guthrie, the third son of James Alexander Guthrie, 4th Baron of Craigie and a Bank of England director, worked in his family’s merchant banking firm, Chalmers, Guthrie & Co., but later devoted himself to renovating Torosay Castle on the Isle of Mull, which he inherited in 1897.
The portrait was created under unusual circumstances. Guthrie’s daughter, Bridget Miller, recalled in a letter that Sargent completed the drawing in just two hours as a gift to her mother. The urgency was due to Guthrie’s declining health, he suffered from diabetes before insulin treatment was available. Despite the hasty execution, the work is widely regarded as one of Sargent’s finest charcoal drawings.
Tragically, Guthrie passed away at the age of 42, just two years after the portrait was made, due to complications from diabetes. Sargent had a long-standing relationship with the Guthrie family, beginning in 1895 when he painted Guthrie’s sister, Agnes Anstruther-Thomson. Over the years, he also created portraits of Guthrie’s other sisters, nephews, and cousins, solidifying his connection with the family.