Skip to content
Back to the Guavy Wire
Stocks

PayPal Trades at Discount Amid Mixed Growth Signals

Instruments
V
Share

PayPal Holdings, Inc. (PYPL) is trading at a discount, raising questions about whether this reflects a bargain opportunity or underlying business challenges. The company's shares have declined about 3.9% over the past year, while competitors Mastercard (MA) and Visa (V) have gained 24.2% and 32.1%, respectively. PayPal's growth prospects hinge on its ability to leverage its large consumer and merchant network amid increasing competition and shifting shopping habits.

Despite a subdued top line, PayPal's third-quarter results show signs of progress. Revenues increased 2% year over year to $8.58 billion, while total payment volume rose 6% to $487.1 billion. Non-GAAP earnings per share advanced 8% to $1.45, supported by spending discipline. Venmo, a key growth driver, saw its payment volume increase 14% to $96.8 billion, and monthly active Venmo debit-card accounts rose more than 55% to 6.7 million. Braintree's processing volume also advanced 10%, supporting PayPal's push into higher-value merchant services.

PayPal generated $2 billion in adjusted free cash flow during the third quarter and repurchased $1.5 billion of shares. Management lifted its 2026 non-GAAP earnings outlook to approximately $5.60 per share from $5.38 and now expects at least $6.5 billion in adjusted free cash flow. These resources are expected to help fund product improvements and shareholder returns without relying solely on faster revenue growth.

The main concern for PayPal remains its online branded checkout, where currency-neutral payment-volume growth was just 1% in the third quarter. Management sees improvement among selected U.S. merchants, but European tariff-related disruptions and persistent competition are slowing the broader recovery. Planned spending on checkout experience, customer engagement, and international expansion may improve results but could limit near-term margin gains.

PayPal shares are trading at a forward 12-month P/E of roughly 10.11 times earnings, compared with 29.08 times for Mastercard and 27.87 times for Visa. While the lower multiple offers some cushion, a lasting revaluation likely depends on healthier checkout growth and sustained transaction-margin improvement. Investors are advised to watch branded-checkout trends, execution against guidance, and the pace of reinvestment before increasing exposure.

More on Stocks